Salads and Dressings
It Starts With a Jar
Long before there was a blog, Mandy was making her own salad dressing. She says she has done it for as long as she can remember, that her mother passed along her vinaigrette wisdom, and that she has passed it along to her daughters in turn. Each of them does it a little differently, but the basic flavors stay the same, with lots of lemon and garlic. That family habit is why this category gives dressings equal billing with the salads they go on.
The method behind her Lemon Vinaigrette Dressing is the lesson worth keeping. Everything goes into a small jar with a lid, and the jar gets shaken. Extra virgin olive oil, a ripe lemon, parsley, dried oregano, dried basil and good quality sea salt take about five minutes to assemble. Once you have done it a few times, you will stop checking the measurements.
How a Dressing Is Actually Put Together
Nearly every dressing on this site has the same three parts: an acid, a fat and something that carries flavor. Change any one of them and you have a different dressing. Comparing Mandy’s recipes side by side shows how far that simple framework can go.
- Lemon Vinaigrette: lemon juice for acid, olive oil for fat, herbs and garlic for flavor.
- Sherry Vinaigrette: sherry and white wine vinegar for acid, olive oil for fat, with scallions, garlic, Dijon mustard and fresh thyme.
- Wicked Good Avocado Dressing: champagne vinegar and lemon for acid, avocado and Greek yogurt for richness.
- Creamy Bleu Cheese Dressing: white wine vinegar for acid, a lighter blend of mayonnaise, sour cream and skim milk for body.
The Sherry Question
Most sherry vinaigrette recipes call for sherry vinegar, and Mandy is happy to say hers does not. She uses actual sherry and combines it with white wine vinegar, on the logic that if you are making sherry vinaigrette, you should use sherry. She keeps a decent bottle in the refrigerator anyway. If all you have is the vinegar, she allows the substitution, while encouraging you to try it her way first.
A Mistake Worth Repeating
The avocado dressing was an accident. Mandy had let an avocado sit too long and did not want to throw it out just because it was no longer pretty. She was on her way to a friend’s house for dinner and in charge of the salad, so she improvised, and the avocado went into the dressing rather than the bowl. Ten minutes and a blender later, she had a recipe that has drawn more reader comments than almost any other dressing here. It is a useful thing to remember the next time you find a soft avocado on the counter.
The bleu cheese dressing has a simpler motivation. Her husband is a huge fan of wedge salads, and she suspects it is really about the bacon and the bleu cheese. She whipped up this version for a special dinner, using lighter dairy, and maintains that it is much better fresh. Spoon it over iceberg and you have a steakhouse starter at home.
Salads With a Story Behind Them
Summer Pasta Salad is an ode to the garden. Between her own vegetables and the farmers markets, Mandy loves picking things and eating them within minutes, still warm from the sun. Her key to this dish is using the freshest ingredients you can get. Fresh basil is a must, as is good extra virgin olive oil, and penne, cherry tomatoes, feta and scallions fill out the bowl. It takes under half an hour and serves eight.
Black Bean Salad was created to go with chipotle shrimp at a Cinco de Mayo dinner, and it also goes nicely with grilled chicken or steak. It holds up as a lunch on its own, too. Black beans, corn, red pepper, cherry tomatoes and scallions need only about 20 minutes, and the flavor adapts to whatever is on the rest of the table.
Asian Chicken Salad came out of a creative night in a cold spring. Mandy made peanut sauce, which led to Sesame Peanut Noodles, which led to this salad of broccoli slaw, shredded carrots, edamame, sliced almonds and scallions. She admits it was a strange combination for one dinner, but her husband was happy to get more than simply a salad.
Carrot Slaw is for anybody who, like Mandy, loves raw carrots for their taste and texture. Shredded carrots, dried cranberries and slivered almonds get tossed with olive oil and red wine vinegar, and resting time lets the dressing soak in. It takes about 45 minutes in all, most of it hands off.
Choosing the Right Pairing
A delicate lettuce wants a thin dressing, and a sturdy one can handle something heavy. Lemon Vinaigrette suits tender greens and the sort of herbs you just picked. Sherry Vinaigrette has enough backbone for roasted vegetables or a salad with nuts. Avocado Dressing belongs on crunchy vegetables that can hold up to its weight, and Bleu Cheese is at its best on a cold, crisp wedge.
Finishing Touches From the Pantry
A salad often gets its personality from the last thing added. Homemade Croutons turn a stale baguette into something you will want to eat by the handful, seasoned with rosemary, oregano and garlic powder. Caramelized Walnuts need only walnuts and sugar, and they bring crunch and a little sweetness to bitter greens. Quick pickles and fresh herbs can do similar work, and all of them cost less than the bottled versions at the grocery store.
Time is rarely the obstacle here. Lemon Vinaigrette takes about five minutes, and the sherry, avocado and bleu cheese dressings about 10 each. Asian Chicken Salad needs about 15 minutes, Black Bean Salad about 20 and Summer Pasta Salad about 27. A homemade dressing takes less time than setting the table, and even the longest salads on this list are ready well before a roast would be.
Every salad and dressing on the site is listed below in alphabetical order. Start with a jar and go from there.










